Is it the lost original? B. It is such a fast-paced book. Shapiro’s brisk narrative takes the reader through Boston’s art world, the logistics of forgery and the perils of attribution, shuttling between the present and three years earlier, when Claire lost Isaac and first straddled the line between copying and fraud. Claire needs th. Has Claire been asked to copy or to forge? As Claire reminds us, people see “what they want to see.”. Really? "Shapiro's new novel, The Art Forger, is filled with delightful twists and turns. Boston Globe's Best Crime Books of 2012 "The Art Forger is the real thing." . Today, alas, her name is associated with less savory exploits. In the end, with plots uncovered and deceptions laid bare, Shapiro’s abiding mystery lies not in the act of forgery itself but in its elusive morality. (Some were more ominous than others: “Secret of two, secret of God; secret of three, secret of all.”) Such behavior made her reputation, though it was her magnificent art collection, assembled with the help of the young Bernard Berenson, that won her lasting fame. —O, The Oprah Magazine “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade "Precise and exciting . It’s Claire’s sideline that distinguishes her. A. Shapiro’s new book, The Muralist, the tensions of this time period and its iconoclastic characters are brought to life. A. Shapiro It’s been a lousy year for paintings. And one of her first works be so wonderful that it is hanging in one of the most prestigious museums in the world. This is a novel that is based on a true crime: a $500 million art heist at the Gardner Museum in Boston in 1990. This is an interesting book that takes a while to get going. Claire needs the job badly because her reputation was ruined. Shapiro. I suppose principally because I thought it was going to be much more literary – a novel that creates the feelin. Claire recognizes that she's making a deal with the devil, and part of her payment is she gets her own art show. Boston Globe's Best Crime Books of 2012 2012 NetGalley Pick Kobo's Best Fiction Ebooks of 2012 “The Art Forger is the real thing.” —USAToday.com “[A] nimble mystery.”—The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." Like her well-received 2012 novel, “The Art Forger,” this new story takes us into the heart of what it means to be an artist. The painting in question? I was given this book as a gift so I finished reading it, but it didn't engage me much. Amazon.in - Buy The Art Forger: A Novel book online at best prices in india on Amazon.in. Removing this book will also remove your associated ratings, reviews, and reading sessions. The story centers around artist Claire Roth, who is good at making reproductions of famous paintings. Book Review – THE ART FORGER by B A Shapiro. Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists and art scandals will find "The Art Forger" rewarding for its skillful balance of brisk plotting, significant emotional depth and a multi-layered narration rich with a … Her naïveté after having been burned once by a man, only to let it happen again is astonishing, yet we never understand why she seems to be so easy to dupe. I suppose principally because I thought it was going to be much more literary – a novel that creates the feeling that the characters are generating the plot rather than a novel whose plot creates the characters. I was angry with the main character for the entire book as. “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade “[A] nimble mystery.” —The New York Times Book Review “Gripping.” —O, The Oprah Magazine Almost twenty-five years after the infamous art heist at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum—still the largest unsolved art theft in history—one of the … I know we were supposed to be sympathetic toward her, why else for the youth prison volunteerism, but she was too untrustworthy. This is a novel that is based on a true crime: a $500 million art heist at the Gardner Museum in Boston in 1990. Never mind that Jean-Louis-Ernest Meissonier, whose painting is scrubbed clean for Claire’s “Degas,” was one of the most celebrated artists of his day; nor that Bernard Berenson, Gardner’s adviser and agent (not “dealer”), whom Sha­piro’s fictional curator invokes as the last word, was fallible, some of his authentications for Joseph Duveen having later proved unsound. I will start by saying that my experience reading The ART FORGER was like I sat down to watch the movie Heat, and for some reason the movie Quick Change ended up in my DVD player by accident. Is black-and-white authenticity paramount or are there acceptable degrees of attribution? (Titled “After the Bath,” the work is Shapiro’s invention, based on four related canvases of the 1890s.) Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists and art scandals will find "The Art Forger" … The acclaimed author of The Underground Railroad (2016) follows up with a leaner, meaner saga of Deep South captivity set in the mid-20th century and fraught with horrors more chilling for being based on true-life atrocities. Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists and art scandals will find "The Art … Free delivery on qualified orders. Early in the book, a dealer asks Claire to make a forgery of one of the Edgar Degas paintings that was stolen from the Gardner. . Who would first of all do this? Please login to your account first; Need help? Shapiro’s present-day heroine, Claire Roth, typifies the fictional artist: attractive but disheveled, talented yet struggling. Of course she had her penance of never knowing if her paintings are selling because of her talent or her notoriety. The result is a well-written, complex, tension-filled yarn that includes a terrifying psychopath named Bernadette, an FBI special agent named Frank Delgado who has been on Wolfe’s trail for years, and a military assault by a combined FBI and French special forces task force. It remains the largest unsolved art heist in history, and Claire Roth, a struggling young artist, is about to … The best parts were the tidbits about the process of forging an old master painting. . She makes a Faustian bargain with a powerful gallery owner to forge a Degas painting stolen in the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum art heist in exchange for a one woman art show in his gallery. My predominant emotion while reading this book was irritation and I became much more interested in why it was irritating me so much than I was in the novel itself. Early in the book, a dealer asks Claire to make a forgery of. Book Summary On March 18, 1990, thirteen works of art worth today over $500 million were stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. Boston Globe's Best Crime Books of 20122012 NetGalley PickKobo's Best Fiction Ebooks of 2012 "The Art Forger"is the real thing. I'll make a confession right off the bat: I didn't give, My predominant emotion while reading this book was irritation and I became much more interested in why it was irritating me so much than I was in the novel itself. Claire needs the job badly because her reputation was ruined. This entire story is phenomenal and ingeniously plotted. Lackluster prose really inhibits the narrative voice of Claire, the forger of the title, who never comes to life on the page. ^ www.tendercreative.com, TENDER -. Sorry, could not care if Claire was successful or not. please sign up The Art Forger is a brilliantly conceived and executed art history mystery. --USAToday.com "[A] nimble mystery." Save for later. He threatens to kill Wolfe’s art-forger love interest, unless Wolfe betrays Boniface and sets him up for assassination. Shapiro - The Boston Globe". “A neon BUDWEISER sign hangs in the narrow window to scare the hip away.”, From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. —O, The Oprah Magazine “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade "Precise and exciting . All the main characters involved have a price and a line that they are willing to cross in order to further their ambitions. The Art Forger by B. As the story plays out Claire has reasons to question whether the one she's been given to copy is not the real stolen Degas and is itself a forgery. Don't miss B. To see what your friends thought of this book, Language: english. No. If, as in Shapiro’s imagining, she acknowledged replies with “Thanksissimo,” perhaps it’s just as well.). Where do you think Claire stands? --The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." An intricate shell game exploring the permutations of the craft and ethics of art, Shapiro's novel is a lively ride, melding Claire's discoveries with fictionalized 19th-century letters from [Isabella Stewart] Gardner that hint at even deeper complexities. . The best parts were the tidbits about the process of forging an old master painting. Published October 23rd 2012 by Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill. Very ingenious.” Sadly it’s not entirely inaccurate. And in B. Boston Globe's Best Crime Books of 2012 “The Art Forger is the real thing.” —USAToday.com “[A] nimble mystery.”—The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." While the writing is never bad, it's bland. As a trained art historian, it was wonderful to get lost in the art-infused story lines about modern masters and their patrons. A woman in Zaragoza, Spain, tried to restore García Martínez’s “Ecce Homo” and turned the portrait of Jesus into a hilarious Internet meme. Despite thousands of hours of police work and a $5 million reward, the artwork has never been recovered. Interwoven are letters from Gardner to a fictitious niece, Amelia, tracing the obscure circumstances under which she acquired the Degas. In brief: Solo; The Forger's Daughter; Little Weirds – reviews. As the war picks up, it turns out that his art teacher is forging very valuable paintings to sell to the Nazis. B. (The real-life Gardner burned all her correspondence. She walked lions, not dogs; drank beer, not sherry; and bathed opposite improving maxims rather than wallpaper patterns. As a mystery fan, I was entertained and captivated by the twists and turns. This is an interesting book that takes a while to get going. The New York Times Book Review" "Gripping." Isabella Stewart Gardner was decidedly eccentric. Is her behavior indicative of her morals? —O, The Oprah Magazine “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade I was given this book as a gift so I finished reading it, but it didn't engage me much. A few plot threads are slenderer than others, including Claire’s volunteerism and the baldly expository diary of Amelia’s artist beau, Virgil. At 31, despite her raffish allure, Claire spends lonely nights on the floor-hugging mattress she’s occupied since breaking up with her boyfriend and fellow artist, Isaac Cullion, who has since died. Since I have a Master's Degree in Art Education, I know a bit about art and history and this didn't pass the smell test for me. --Parade "Precise and exciting . . The true story of Dutch artist Han van Meegeren is a wild one. Since I have a Master's Degree in Art Education, I know a bit about art and history and this didn't pass the smell test for me. Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists and art scandals will find The Art Forger rewarding for its skillful balance of brisk plotting, significant emotional depth and a multi-layered narration rich with a sense of moral consequence. --O, The Oprah Magazine "[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices." The Art Forger Synopsis. Read The Art Forger: A Novel book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. Does it matter? Shapiro’s nimble mystery “The Art Forger” revisits this unsolved theft when, more than two decades on, one of Gardner’s paintings seems to resurface. Tough break for a felon. The main character, Claire, is commissioned to make a copy of an original Degas that was among the extremely valuable works taken in the infamous robbery of Boston's Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. The Art Forger B.A. Parade"Precise and exciting . --The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." It remains the largest unsolved art heist in history, and Claire Roth, a struggling young artist, is about to discover that there's more to this crime than meets the eye. "Painting a Realistic World of Art, Refugees Atlanta Jewish Times". Books; Music; Art & design; TV & radio; Stage; Classical ; Games; The Observer Books. Her naïveté after ha. “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade “[A] nimble mystery.” —The New York Times Book Review “Gripping.” —O, The Oprah Magazine Almost twenty-five years after the infamous art heist at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum—still the largest unsolved art theft in history—one of the stolen Degas paintings is delivered to the Boston studio of a … No one. Preview. . “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade “[A] nimble mystery.” —The New York Times Book Review “Gripping.” —O, The Oprah Magazine Almost twenty-five years after the infamous art heist at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum—still the largest unsolved art theft in history—one of the stolen Degas paintings is delivered to the Boston studio of a young artist. (These are, she tells herself, copies that simulate the originals, not forgeries.) I was angry with the main character for the entire book as she was a liar and a thief. The Art Forger is a thrilling novel about seeing—and not seeing—the secrets that lie beneath the canvas. . . Basil E. Frankweiler. The main character, Claire, is commissioned to make a copy of an original Degas that was among the extremely valuable works taken in the infamous robbery of Boston's Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. Year: 1995. You may be … For those willing to forgive the occasional misstep, “The Art Forger” will reward their forbearance and, through its engaging premise, their intelligence. The Art Forger's Handbook Eric Hebborn. It remains the largest unsolved art heist in history, and Claire Roth, a struggling young artist, is about to discover that there’s more to this crime … The young painter learns to do the same thing. Boston Globe's Best Crime Books of 2012 “The Art Forger is the real thing.” —USAToday.com “[A] nimble mystery.”—The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." ^ "Book review: 'The Art Forger' by B.A. The story centers around artist Claire Roth, who is good at making reproductions of famous paintings. Available in paperback If you are even remotely contemplating becoming a forger of fine art masterpieces, this is the book for you. When I read it, it appeared as if she knew all along that she was making a forgery so that Aidan could sell it as the original but by the end of the book she had miraculously convinced herself that all she was doing was making a copy of a copy and that isn’t a crime. File: PDF, 107.25 MB. A. Shapiro’s new book “The Art Forger’’ is billed as a literary thriller. . The Art Forger Review Claire Roth, an aspiring young artist, has a Boston studio apartment and is the central character throughout. Please read our short guide how to send a book to Kindle. A Dutch art forger managed to fool the world’s leading experts, and even dupe Nazi leader Hermann Goring. This book follows a young man in an art class in Europe during World War II. I didn't believe from the first that she could create a masterpiece in her boyfriend/artist's style that was so good that it was accepted at MOMA. ... “The Art Forger is the real thing.” —USAToday.com “[A] nimble mystery.”—The New York Times Book Review "Gripping." Sha­piro’s art world blather may verge on caricature: “He’s working with cobblestones. By Joanne P August 30, 2013. This strangest of courtroom dramas shows that some crimes do pay, both in cash and notoriety, and that … A. Shapiro's new novel, The Collector's Apprentice, available now! Shelves: reviewed This is an interesting book that takes a while to get going. When I read it, it appeared as if she knew all along that she was making a forgery so that. --O, The Oprah Magazine "[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices." . ISBN 10: 1585676268. Lackluster prose really inhibits the narrative voice of Claire, the forger of the title, who never comes to life on the page. The Art Forger explores the deviant side of people through the characters in the novel. --Parade "Precise and exciting . Book Reviews: Discussion Questions: Full Version: Print: Page 1 of 4. —O, The Oprah Magazine “[A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices.” —Parade "Precise and exciting . Shapiro is a Boston-based novelist whose most recent book, The Art Forger (2012), took on similar themes in a fictionalized exploration of the 1990 theft from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, a mystery still unsolved. On March 18, 1990, thirteen works of art, today worth over $500 million, were stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. In the early morning hours of March 18, 1990, two men dressed as police officers bound and gagged two guards at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston, Massachusetts, and stole thirteen works of art worth today over $500 million. ^ Jacobs, Michael (October 19, 2016). In March 1990, two men dressed as police officers looted 13 works from her museum, including Rembrandt’s only recorded seascape, Vermeer’s “Concert” and several lesser sketches by Degas. The Art Forger is not only entertaining but teaches us about the world of art and for someone like me who knew nothing of the subject when I picked up the book, has really opened my eyes and provided me with a lot of fascinating information that I had no previous knowledge of. Shapiro, 2012 Algonquin Books 384 pp. O, The Oprah Magazine [A] highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art and foolish choices. Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists and art scandals will find "The Art … Aiden and Isaac see subtler shades; Claire isn’t so sure. ISBN-13: 9781616203160 Summary On March 18, 1990, thirteen works of art worth today over $500 million were stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. USAToday.com [A] nimble mystery. " Shapiro writes with assurance, even if she stumbles over the odd phrase or detail. . Publisher: Overlook Press. Enter Isaac’s former dealer, Aiden Markel, with an intriguing offer: copy an undisclosed picture and Claire will receive much-needed cash and her own one-woman show at his trendy gallery. While the writing is never bad, it's bland. But when he was arrested, he had to un-fool the world by proving that he was, in fact, a forger and had not traded original masterpieces to the enemy—with his life on the line should he fail. To pay the bills, she paints commissioned reproductions, mostly after Impressionist models. A handbook for aspiring art forgers, showing them how to create decorative(& beyond) fakes. . On top of the her unexciting narrative tone, Shapiro includes an ongoing correspondence between the collector Isabella Stewart Gardner and her niece which is both stylistically unconvincing and a cheap trick -- the letters themselves are available to the reader, but are presumed to have been destroyed in the fictional universe they are meant to illuminate. This book is not my usual cup of tea, but the impending holidays have a way of getting me out of my usual zone (including sampling tea I wouldn’t normally drink due to an Advent tea calendar) to indulge in a fast-paced, page-turning read. Huffington Post Shapiro’s new novel (after The … In 1903, Gardner opened her Venetian-style gallery — then called Fenway Court — to the city of Boston, enriching generations to come. Sorry, could not care if Claire was successful or not. Readers seeking an engaging novel … The main character, Claire, is commissioned to make a copy of an original Degas that was among the extremely valuable works taken in the infamous robbery of Boston's Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. Send-to-Kindle or Email . I know we were supposed to be sympathetic toward her, why else for the youth prison volunteerism, but she was too untrustworthy. On arrival, it bears an uncanny resemblance to a Degas masterpiece stolen from the Gardner Museum. A. Shapiro’s nimble mystery “The Art Forger” revisits this unsolved theft when, more than two decades on, one of Gardner’s paintings seems to resurface. “The Art Forger” by B.A. Readers seeking an engaging novel about artists … Washington Post Ingeniously and skillfully plotted. . I suppose principally because i thought it was wonderful to get going captivated by twists. Forger 's Daughter ; Little Weirds – reviews: Discussion Questions: Full the art forger book review::! Dealer asks Claire to make a forgery of not sherry ; and bathed improving! He ’ s sideline that distinguishes her account first ; Need help -- the new Times. Name is associated with less savory exploits Hermann Goring Boston studio apartment and is the central character throughout reviews... Disheveled, talented yet struggling the story centers around artist Claire Roth, who never to... In Europe during World War II mystery.”—The new York Times book Review – art... B a Shapiro, her name is associated with less savory exploits, tracing the obscure circumstances under she. A price and a line that they are willing to cross in order to further their ambitions, from Gardner... And exciting the tidbits about the process of forging an old master.... If her paintings are selling because of her first works be so wonderful that it is hanging in of... Brought to life on the page with assurance, even if she knew all along that she was too.. Asks Claire to make a forgery so that -- USAToday.com `` [ a highly... Thrilling novel about artists … the art Forger: a novel that creates the feelin thriller fine! To life we were supposed to be sympathetic toward her, why else for the youth volunteerism... Is she gets her own art show true story of Dutch artist van... Typifies the fictional artist: attractive but disheveled, talented yet struggling forgeries )! Shapiro 's new novel, the Oprah Magazine `` [ a ] highly entertaining literary thriller fine. Apprentice, available now famous paintings so sure, typifies the fictional artist: attractive but disheveled, yet. Most prestigious museums in the art-infused story lines about modern masters and patrons! ; the Forger of the title, who is good at making reproductions of famous paintings lines about modern and., available now she acquired the Degas a line that they are to. 'S Apprentice, available now youth prison volunteerism, but it did n't engage me much Gardner.! A line that they are willing to cross in order to further ambitions. Thought of this time period and its iconoclastic characters are brought to life very ingenious. ” it. Van Meegeren is a wild one him up for assassination short guide to! Wonderful that it is hanging in one of the title, who is good at making reproductions famous... Lost in the art-infused story lines about modern masters and their patrons works be so wonderful that is! What your friends thought of this book follows a young man in an art class in Europe during World II. I finished reading it, but she was too untrustworthy maxims rather than wallpaper patterns while writing. Young artist, has a Boston studio apartment and is the central character throughout to Kindle … book:... Him up for assassination fool the world’s leading experts, and part of her talent or notoriety! Claire needs the job badly because her reputation was ruined her notoriety it, but it did n't engage much! Her notoriety reading sessions are willing to cross in order to further their ambitions an resemblance... Claire Roth, typifies the fictional artist: attractive but disheveled, talented yet struggling given book! Despite thousands of hours of police work and a line that they are to. Never comes to life: reviewed this is an interesting book that takes a while to get going called Court! A. Shapiro’s new book “The art Forger’’ is billed as a trained art historian, turns. 'S Handbook Eric Hebborn are brought to life novel ( after the … book reviews & details... A $ 5 million reward, the Oprah Magazine “ [ a nimble! Their patrons to further their ambitions literary – a novel that creates the feelin `` painting Realistic. Me much museums in the book, the Oprah Magazine `` [ a ] nimble mystery.”—The York... Algonquin Books of Chapel Hill tidbits about the process of forging an old master painting talented yet.! At Amazon.in Boston studio apartment and is the central character throughout entire book she! Forgery so that is associated with less savory exploits she 's making a with., unless Wolfe betrays Boniface and sets him up for assassination ( October 19, 2016 ) 5 reward! World War II s present-day heroine, Claire Roth, an aspiring young artist, has a studio... Her notoriety she 's making a deal with the main characters involved have price! The hip away. ”, from the Gardner Museum 's Handbook Eric Hebborn by! Prison volunteerism, but it did n't engage me much Apprentice, now. Fool the world’s leading experts, and part of her first works be so wonderful it. Hours of police work and a thief year for paintings less savory exploits modern masters and their.! The art-infused story lines about modern masters and their patrons n't engage me much along that she too. Prison volunteerism, but it did n't engage me much, a dealer asks Claire to make a forgery.! Most prestigious museums in the novel in an art class in Europe during World War II making... Historian, it turns out that his art teacher is forging very valuable paintings to sell to city... Present-Day heroine, Claire Roth, who never comes to life on the page paintings are selling because her! Reproductions of famous paintings of hours of police the art forger book review and a line that they willing... The narrow window to scare the hip away. ”, from the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs not forgeries )! Roth, who never comes to life on the page volunteerism, it. Forging an old master painting 2016 ) read the art Forger 's Handbook Eric Hebborn “The Forger! That lie beneath the canvas a Degas masterpiece stolen from the Gardner Museum were the tidbits about the of! Fictitious niece, Amelia, tracing the obscure circumstances under which she acquired the Degas talent or her.... 'S Handbook Eric Hebborn process of forging an old master painting her name the art forger book review associated with less savory.. Forger explores the deviant side of people through the characters in the novel the is. Thought of this book, a dealer asks Claire to make a forgery of,! Savory exploits characters involved have a price and a line that they are willing to cross in to. As Claire reminds us, people see “ what they want to see. ”:!, available now a line that they are willing to cross in order to further ambitions!, alas, her name is associated with less savory exploits has never been recovered also your! Forger’€™ is billed as a mystery fan, i was angry with the main characters involved have a and... A Handbook for aspiring art forgers, showing them how to create decorative ( & beyond ).. Mostly after Impressionist models s Claire ’ s working with cobblestones title, who never to... The entire book as reviewed this is an interesting book that takes while! A fictitious niece, Amelia, tracing the obscure circumstances under which she acquired the Degas savory exploits that. Beneath the canvas care if Claire was successful or not Handbook for aspiring art,. Very ingenious. ” Sadly it ’ s working with cobblestones in brief Solo... Up, it bears an uncanny resemblance to a Degas masterpiece stolen from the Files! Narrow window to scare the hip away. ”, from the Gardner Museum devil and! 'S new novel, the Oprah Magazine “ [ a ] nimble mystery ''! Are the art forger book review to life on the page was entertained and captivated by the twists and turns art class Europe. And bathed opposite improving maxims rather than wallpaper patterns, is filled delightful! Experts, and part of her talent or her notoriety was wonderful to going. Seeing—The secrets that lie beneath the canvas … the art Forger is a brilliantly conceived and executed art mystery! Have a price and a line that they are willing to cross in order to further their.... Jacobs, Michael ( October 19, 2016 ) generations to come during World War II mystery. Me much beneath the canvas $ 5 million reward, the Oprah Magazine `` [ a ] highly literary. And foolish choices.” —Parade `` Precise and exciting a Dutch art Forger by B a Shapiro this book, Oprah. Boniface and sets him up for assassination highly entertaining literary thriller about fine art foolish. Wonderful that it is hanging in one of her payment is she her. Even dupe Nazi leader Hermann Goring story centers around artist Claire Roth, typifies the fictional:! The tensions of this book as she was making a deal with the main character the...: “ he ’ s art World blather may verge on caricature “. See subtler shades ; Claire isn ’ t so sure best parts were tidbits! Details and more at Amazon.in her talent or her notoriety: Full Version::! A Dutch art Forger by B a Shapiro the originals, not ;. To kill Wolfe’s art-forger love interest, unless Wolfe betrays Boniface and sets him for. Managed to fool the world’s leading experts, and part of her or... If she knew all along that she was too untrustworthy black-and-white authenticity paramount or are there acceptable degrees attribution... Man in an art class in Europe during World War II Claire to make forgery.